Matin Research Journal

Matin Research Journal

Readdressing the Issue of Tashhir (Public Exposure) in Imamiyah Jurisprudence (With an Analysis of Imam Khomeini’s Views)

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
1 Assistant Professor, Department of Islamic Jurisprudence and Law, Bozorgmehr University of Qaenat, Qaenat, Iran
2 Assistant Professor, Department of Jurisprudence and Law, Payam Nour University, PO Box 19395-4697, Tehran, Iran
Abstract
In Imamiyah penal jurisprudence, Tashhir or publicly shaming of an offender, for some reasons, is an exception to the principle of preserving the honor of people and refraining from revealing secrets of Muslims. With respect to the importance of abandoning one’s right and the need for preserving honor and dignity of people, this paper intends to extract instances of verdicts on publicly shaming of offenders from the legacy of jurisprudence in an analytical way. Findings of the paper, achieved through a descriptive-analytical method, indicate that except in one case, i.e. “false testimony”, examples of crimes brought up by the jurists such as Ghiadat (complicity in crime), Ghazf (attributing adultery to someone), Ehtial (fraud), Tadlis (criminal misrepresentation), and Eflas (debt for insolvency) lack valid documentation. Therefore, as the presumption goes, lack of evidence for a crime is regarded as an evidence for its non-existence. Therefore, Tashhir, except in cases up to the certainty, must be practiced with caution as a means of punishment and invoking a juridical rule on punishment shall suffice for the offender. An analysis of Imam Khomeini’s view on this issue indicates that he openly supports practicing Tashhir only for false testimony. This, however, must be added that according to Imam Khomeini, practicing some forms of punishment (including Tashhir) in some certain cases and crimes with public dimension shall be permissible at the discretion of the government and under subsequent titles.
Keywords

Subjects


  • A group of researchers, under the supervision of Seyed Mahmoud Hashemi Shahroudi.(2005) Jurisprudence according to the religion of Ahl al-Bayt (AS), 3 volumes, Qom: Institute of Islamic Jurisprudence on the Madhhab of Ahl al-Bayt, peace be upon them, first edition. (In Persian)
  • Allameh Helli, Hasan bin Youssef.(1992) Qawaeid al-ahkam fi maerifat al-halal w ‏al-haram, 3 volumes, Islamic Publications Office, Qom, first edition. (In Arabic)
  • Allameh Helli, Hasan bin Youssef.(1993) Tadhkirat alfuqaha'i(ta- alhadithah), 14 volumes, Qom: Aal-al-Bayt Institute, first edition. (In Arabic)
  • Allameh Helli, Hasan bin Youssef.(1999) Tahrir al-Ahkam al-shareia eilaa madhhab al-imamiyah, 6 volumes, Qom: Institute of Imam Sadiq, peace be upon him, first edition. (In Arabic)
  • Allameh Helli, Hasan bin Youssef.(1989) Irshad al'adhhan 'ilaa 'ahkam al'iman, Qom: Islamic Publications Office, first edition. (In Arabic)
  • Ameli, Seyyed Javad bin Mohammad.(1998) Miftah al-Karamah fi Sharh qawaeid al-Allamah (t-al-hadith), 23 volumes, Qom: Islamic Publications Office, first edition. (In Arabic)
  • Ardabili, Ahmad bin Mohammad.(1982) Majmae ol-fayidah w al burhan fi sharh irshad al'adhhan,14 volumes, Qom: Islamic Publications Office, first edition. (In Arabic)
  • Behjat Fomani, Mohammad Taqi.(2005) Jame' Al-Masal, 5 volumes, Qom: Moazzam Allah office, second edition. (In Persian)
  • Farahidi, Khalil bin Ahmad.(1989) Kitab al-Ayn, 8 volumes, Qom: Hijrat Publishing, second edition. (In Arabic)
  • Fazel Hendi, Mohammad bin Hassan.(1995) Kashf al-litham w al-ebham an qawaeid al-ahkam, 11 volumes, Qom: Islamic Publications Office, first edition.
  • Fazel Lankarani, Mohammad Movahedi.(2001) Tafsil al-sharieah fi sharh tahrir al-wasilah- alhudud, in one volume , Qom: jurisprudence institute of Aemmah Athar,peace be upon them, first edition. (In Arabic)
  • Feyz Kashani, Mohammad Mohsen Ibn Shah Mortaza, Mafatih al-Sharayea, Qom : Ayatollah Marashi Library, first edition. (In Arabic)
  • First Majlisi, Mohammad Taqi.(1985) Rauwzat al-Muttaqin fi Sharh Man la Yahduruh al-Faqih, 13 volumes, Qom: Kushanbur Islamic Cultural Institute, second edition. (In Arabic)
  • Gholami, Ali; Mojtahdi, Mohammad Hossein; Tahmasabi, Mohammad Hassan. (2017) “Punishment for scandal in punishment [Ta’dhirat] (with a comparative approach to punishments based on shame in the United States)”, Legal Journal of Justice, year 82, winter. (In Persian)
  • Golpaygani, Seyyed Mohammad Reza Mousavi. (1992) Al-Dar al-Mandud Fi Ahkam al-Hudud, Qom: Dar al-Qur'an al-Karim.
  • Halabi, Abu al-Salah, Taqi-al-Din bin Najm-al-Din.(1982) Al-Kafi fi Fiqh, Isfahan: Amir al-Momenin Library, first edition. (In Arabic)
  • Helli, Yahya bin Saeed.(1984) Al-Jamae li sharayiei, in one volume, Qom: Sayed Al-Shuhada Al-Elamiya Foundation, first edition. (In Arabic)
  • Hemyari, Abdullah bin Jafar. (1992) Qurb al-Isnad, in one volume, Qom: Aal- al bayt Institution, peace be upon them, first edition. (In Arabic)
  • Hemyari, Nashwaan bin Saeed.(1999) Shams al-Uloom w dawa' kalam al arab min al kalum, 12 volumes, Beirut: Dar al-Fekr al muasir, first edition. (In Arabic)
  • Heydari, Ali morad.(2013) "Criminal Criticism of Media scandal", Islamic Law, 10th Year, Number 38. (In Persian)
  • Ibn al'athir, mubarak bin muhamad, Alnihayat fi ghurayeb al-hadith w al'athar, Qom: Ismailian,first edition. (In Arabic)
  • Ibn Baraj.(1985) Qazi Abdul Aziz, 2 volumes, Qom: Islamic Publishing office, first edition.
  • Ibn Hamzah, Mohammad bin Ali.(1987) Al-Wasilah 'ilaa neyl al-fadilah, Qom: Ayatollah Marashi Library Publications. (In Arabic)
  • Ibn Idris, Mohammad Ibn Mansour.(1989) Al-Sara'er al-Hawi Le tahrir al-Fatawaa, Qom: Islamic Publications Office, second edition. (In Arabic)
  • Ibn Manzoor, Mohammad Ibn Mukram. (1993) Lesan al-arab, 15 volumes, Beirut: Daar al-fikr for printing and publishing,. (In Arabic)
  • Ibn Zohra, Hamzah bin Ali Hosseini. (1996) Ghaniah al-nuzue' ilaa elmy al-osoul wal forue, Qom: Institute of Imam Sadiq, peace be upon him, first edition. (In Arabic)
  • Johari, Ismail bin Hammad.(1989) Al-sahaah Taj al-lughat w sahaah al-arabiyah, Beirut: Daar al-elm lil malayin, first edition. (In Arabic)
  • Khansari, Seyyed Ahmad.(1984) Jame al- madarik fi sharh mukhtasar al naafiei, Qom: Ismailian Institute, second edition. (In Arabic)
  • Khoi, Seyyed abo al-qasim.(2001) Mabani takmilah alminhaj,2 volumes, Qom: Imam Al-Khoi Works Restoration Foundation, first edition. (In Persian)
  • Khomeini, Seyyed Ruhollah.(2000)Tahrir al-Wasila, in one volume, Tehran: Imam Khomeini (PBUH), editing and publishing institute, first edition. (In Persian)
  • Khomeini, Seyyed Ruhollah. (2006) ) Collection of Imam Works (22-volume series), Tehran: Imam Khomeini Publishing House, 4th edition. (In Persian)
  • Kidari, Qutb al-Din, Mohammad bin Hossein.(1995) Isbah al-Shi'a be Misbah al-Sharia, Qom: Imam Sadiq Institute, first edition. (In Arabic)
  • Koleini, Mohammad bin Yaqoob.(1986) Al-Kafi(ta- al'islamiah), 8 volumes, Tehran: Daar al-Kotob al-Islamiyah, 4th edition. (In Arabic)
  • Maghrebi, No’man bin Mohammad Tamimi.(2006) Da’ayim al-islam, 2 volumes, Qom: Aal Al-Bayt (peace be upon them) Institute, 2nd edition. (In Arabic)
  • Majlisi II, Mohammad Baqer bin Mohammad Taqi.(n.d) Hudud wa Qisas wa Diyat, Tehran: Islamic Works Publishing Institute, first edition. (In Persian)
  • Majlisi II, Mohammad Baqer bin Mohammad Taqi (1983) Miraat al-oqool fi sharh akhbar Aal al-rasoul, 26 volumes, Tehran: Islamic Darul-Kitab, second edition. (In Arabic)
  • Majlisi II, Mohammad Baqer bin Mohammad Taqi (1985) Maladh al'akhyar fi fahm tahdhib al'akhbar, 16 volumes, Qom: Ayatollah Marashi Najafi Library Publications, 1st edition. (In Arabic)
  • Meshkini, Mirza Ali.(1998) Terms of Jurisprudence, in one volume, Qom: Al-Hadi publishing, first edition. (In Persian)
  • Mofid, Mohammad bin Mohammad. (1992) Al-Moqna'a, in one volume, Qom : Millennium of Sheikh Mofid World Congress, first edition. (In Arabic)
  • Mohaghegh Damad, Seyyed Mustafa.(1985) Jurisprudence Rules, 4 volumes, Tehran: Islamic Sciences Publishing Center, , 12th edition. (In Persian)
  • Mohaghegh Helli, Jafar bin Hassan.(1987) Sharayie al'Islam fi masayil al-halal w ‏al-haram, 4 volumes, Qom: Ismailian Institute, second edition. (In Arabic)
  • Mohaghegh Helli, Jafar bin Hassan. (1997) Al-Mukhtasar al-Nafia’ fi Fiqh al-Imamiyah, Qom: Foundation for religious publications, , 6th edition. (In Arabic)
  • Momen Qomi, Mohammad.(2001) Mabani tahrir al-wasilah- Kitab al-hudud, in one volume, Tehran: Imam Khomeini Works Editing and Publishing Institute, first edition. (In Persian)
  • Montazeri, Hossein Ali. (1988) The Jurisprudential Foundations of Islamic Government, translator: Salavati, Mahmoud and Shakouri, Abul, 8 volumes, Qom: Kayhan Institute, first edition. (In Persian)
  • Mostafavi, Hassan.(1981) Al-Tahghigh fi Kalamat al-Qur'an al-Karim, 14 volumes, Tehran: Center for Translation and Publishing, 1st edition. (In Arabic)
  • Mousavi Ardebili, Seyyed Abd al-Karim. (2006) Jurisprudence of Hudud and Ta'zirat, Qom: Al-Mufid University Publishing Institution, second edition. (In Persian)
  • Mughniyeh, Mohammad Javad.(2000) Jurisprudence of Imam Sadiq, peace be upon him, 6 volumes, Qom: Ansarian Institute, second edition. (In Arabic)
  • Muhaddith Nouri, Mirza Hossein.(1987) Mustardak al-Wasa’il wa Mustanbat al-Mas’eal, 18 volumes, Beirut: Al-Bayt Institute (AS), first edition. (In Arabic)
  • Najafi, Mohammad Hassan.(1983) Jawahir al-Kalam fi sharh sharayie al'islam, 43 volumes, Beirut: House of Revival of Arab Heritage, 7th edition. (In Arabic)
  • Naraghi, Ahmad bin Mohammad Mahdi.(1996) Awaed al-Ayyam fi Bayan Qawaed al-Ahkam, in one volume, Qom: Publications of Tablighat Islami, first edition. (In Arabic)
  • Qorashi, Seyyed Ali Akbar.(1991) Qamus Qur'an, 7 volumes, Tehran: Islamic Books, 6th edition. (In Persian)
  • Rawandi, Saeed bin Abdullah.(1984) Fiqh al-Qur'an, 2 volumes, Qom: Ayatollah Marashi Najafi Library Publications, second edition. (In Arabic)
  • Rouhani, Seyyed Sadiq.(1991) Fiqh al-Sadiq (a.s.), 26 volumes, Qom: Daar al-Kitab-Madrasah Imam Sadiq (a.s.), first edition. (In Arabic)
  • Sabzevari, Seyyed Abd al-Ali.(1992) Mohadzab al-Ahkam, 30 volumes, Qom: Al-Manar Institute, 4th edition. (In Arabic)
  • Sadouq, Mohammad bin Ali bin Babouyeh.(1992) Man la yahduroh al-faqihi, 4 volumes, Qom: Islamic Publications Office, second edition. (In Arabic)
  • Safaei, Seyyed Hossein.(2013) Civil Law Introductory Course (General Rules of Contracts), Tehran: Mizan, second edition. (In Persian)
  • Sahib ibn Abbad, Ismail bin Abbad.(1993) Al-Mohidt fi al-Loghah, Beirut: Aalam al-Kitab, first edition. (In Arabic)
  • Salar Dailami, Hamzah bin Abdul Aziz. (1983) Al-Marasim al-Alawiya and al-Ahkam al-Nabawiyya, Qom: Al-Haramain Publications, first edition. (In Arabic)
  • Shaheed Thani, Zain al-Din bin Ali.(1992) Masalik al-Afham 'ilaa tanqih sharayie al-islam, Qom: Islamic Encyclopaedia Foundation, first edition. (In Arabic)
  • Shaheed Thani, Zain al-Din bin Ali. (1989) Al-Rawda al-Bahiyya fi Sharh al-Loma' al-Dameshqiyya, Qom: Davari, first edition. (In Arabic)
  • Sharif Morteza, Ali bin Hossein Mousavi (1994). Al-Intisar fi Infradat al-Imamiya, in one volume, Qom: Islamic Publications Office affiliated to the Qom Seminary Society of Teachers, first edition. (In Arabic)
  • Shobeiri Zanjani, Seyed Moussa.(2007) Al-Masael al-Shareiyah, in one volume, Qom: Al-Fiqahah Publishing foundation, first edition. (In Arabic)
  • Soltani, Abbas Ali; Mohaddisi, Zahra.(2016) An attitude on the punishment of scandal in Shia jurisprudence with a looking at the relevant laws", Researches in Islamic jurisprudence and law, No 49, autumn. (In Persian)
  • Tabatabai Haeri, Seyyed Ali Bin Mohammad.(1997) Riyad al-Masail, 16 volumes, Qom: Al-Bayt Institute, first edition. (In Arabic)
  • Tabrizi, Javad Bin Ali. (1996) Ussas al-hudud wal ta'azirat, in one volume, Qom: author's office, first edition. (In Arabic)
  • Tareehi, Fakhreddin.(1995) Majma’a al-Bahrain, 6 volumes, Tehran: Mortazavi bookstore, third edition. (In Persian)
  • Tousi, Mohammad bin Hasan.(2008) Al-Mabsut fi Fiqh al-Imamiya, 8 volumes, Tehran: al-Murtazawii Library, third edition. (In Arabic)
  • Tousi, Mohammad bin Hasan. (1979) Alnihayah fi mujarad al-fiqh w al-fatawaa, Beirut: Daar al-Kitab al-Arabi, 2nd edition. (In Arabic)
  • Tousi, Mohammad bin Hasan. (1986) Tahdhib al'ahkam, 10 volumes, Tehran: Islamic Books, 4th edition (In Persian).
  • Tousi, Mohammad bin Hasan. (1986) Al-Khalaf, 6 volumes, Qom: Islamic Publications Office, first edition. (In Arabic)
  • Vahid Khorasani, Hossein. (2007) Minhaj al-Salehin, 3 volumes, Qom:Imam Baqir school, peace be upon him, 5th. (In Arabic)
  • Zamakhshari, Mahmoud bin umar.(1996) Al-fayiq fi gharib al-hadith, 4 volumes, Beirut: Daar al-Ketab Al-Elamiya, first edition. (In Arabic)
  • Zamani, Leila; Abuei, Hossein; Tawalaei, Ali.(2010) Disgrace the witness of force" Tashhir Shahid Zoor, Two-quarter journal of jurisprudence and fundamentals of Islamic law, year 44, No 2, autumn and winter. (In Persian)
  • Zubaydi, Seyyed Mohammad Mortaza.(1993)Taj al-Arus Man Javaher al-Qamoos, Beirut: Dar al-Fakr, first edition. (In Arabic)